Mathura Sridharan, Ohio's new solicitor general, faces racist backlash for wearing bindi

Mathura Sridharan, a distinguished Indian-origin lawyer, has recently been appointed as Ohio’s 12th solicitor general—a prestigious legal role that places her at the forefront of the state’s most significant appellate litigation. Her appointment, however, has unwittingly sparked controversy on social media, not for her impressive credentials, but for her decision to wear a traditional ‘bindi’ on her forehead during her official duties.

Social media criticism over identity

After the announcement of her appointment, several social media users began targeting Sridharan for wearing a bindi, with some questioning her American identity and loyalty. One widely shared comment read, “Is she a Christian? That’s the biggest factor that concerns me. Based on the bindi on her forehead, I worry she is not. That absolutely should matter to us when choosing our leaders.”

Others were more direct, with one user stating, “She’s Indian. They all have a loyalty first to other Indians. Horrible pick. Totally un-American,” while another commented, “Why would you select someone who isn’t an American for such an important role?” These remarks not only questioned her suitability but also revealed underlying prejudices about the cultural diversity present in American public offices.

Vocal support from Ohio’s Attorney General

Responding to the criticism, Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost issued a strong defence of Sridharan. In a public statement, Yost clarified, “A few commenters have asserted incorrectly that Mathura is not American.”

He confirmed that Sridharan is a US citizen, married to a US citizen, and the child of naturalized US citizens. Yost further remarked, “If her name or her complexion bother you, the problem is not with her or her appointment.” His supportive remarks highlighted not only Sridharan’s American identity but also her outstanding qualifications and professional recognition.

Legal acumen and professional achievements

Dave Yost praised Sridharan, describing her as “brilliant” and highlighting her successful argument before the US Supreme Court in Ohio v. EPA, a case concerning environmental regulations and interstate air pollution. Both solicitors general she previously worked under—Flowers and Gaiser—highly recommended her for the appointment.

Sridharan served as the Deputy Solicitor General in Ohio’s Office of the Solicitor General, bringing significant experience in appellate advocacy. Her path into the role was paved by earlier clerkship positions with Judge Steven J. Menashi on the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and with Judge Deborah A. Batts of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Mathura Sridharan’s academic pedigree is equally distinguished. She holds a Juris Doctor from the New York University School of Law, a Master’s degree in Electrical Engineering & Computer Science from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), and a Bachelor’s degree in both Economics and Electrical Engineering & Computer Science from MIT.