Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Submit Guest Post

What really happened in Shanaya Kapoor's 'not so conventional' 'Student Of The Year' series

Bollywood actor Shanaya Kapoor steps into a challenging double role in JioHotstar's dark reinvention of the Student Of The Year franchise. While murder, psychological trauma and campus rivalries offer a fresh premise, uneven writing weakens the thriller.

What really happened in Shanaya Kapoor's 'not so conventional' 'Student Of The Year' series

Streaming on JioHotstar, the six-episode Hindi thriller is directed by Reema Maya and stars Shanaya Kapoor, Divik Sharma, Manya Grover, Abhinav Singh and Deeya Damini.

Forget the designer wardrobes, dance competitions and glossy romances. Student Of The Year: After Dark turns St. Teresa Heritage School into a chilling world of murder, toxic friendships, psychological trauma and hidden rivalries. Shanaya Kapoor makes a promising attempt in a challenging double role, but the series struggles to deliver a mystery worthy of its dark premise.

The Student Of The Year franchise has taken a sharp turn. The familiar campus of St. Teresa Heritage School is no longer about popularity, extravagant parties and students competing for a coveted trophy. In its latest installment, Student Of The Year: After Dark, the stakes are far more disturbing: a student is dead, her twin sister wants answers, and almost everyone appears to have something to hide.


Streaming on JioHotstar, the six-episode Hindi thriller is directed by Reema Maya and stars Shanaya Kapoor, Divik Sharma, Manya Grover, Abhinav Singh and Deeya Damini. The series attempts to combine a murder mystery with a psychological drama about teenage relationships, family problems, grief and the pressure to fit in.

But while the darker reinvention is an interesting idea, the execution does not always match its ambition.

Rating: 2.5/5

A Frozen Body, a Twin Sister and a School Full of Suspects

The story begins with Aayesha Malik, played by Shanaya Kapoor, being found dead in a frozen lake. A popular student at the prestigious St. Teresa Heritage School, Aayesha appears to have had the kind of life many of her classmates envy.

Her twin sister Aditi, also played by Kapoor, refuses to accept the circumstances surrounding her death. Determined to uncover the truth, she enters the same school and begins investigating what happened to her sister.

However, this is not a straightforward investigation. Aditi finds herself caught up in the school's competitive Student of the Year contest, while navigating a complicated circle of friends, former lovers, jealous classmates and suspicious adults. The boyfriend has his own baggage, the best friend may not be as loyal as she appears, and even the school's authority figures seem to have secrets.

The premise has enough potential to create a tense campus thriller. The school becomes a closed world where popularity, ambition and personal grudges can turn dangerous. The problem is that the series keeps introducing new suspicions and twists without always developing them into a convincing mystery.

Shanaya Kapoor's Double Role Is the Biggest Attraction

The most interesting aspect of After Dark is Shanaya Kapoor's opportunity to play two contrasting characters. Aayesha is confident, popular and comfortable in the spotlight, while Aditi is more guarded, emotionally wounded and determined to find answers.

Kapoor attempts to distinguish the sisters through their expressions, body language and overall screen presence. Aditi, in particular, gives her an opportunity to move away from a conventional glamorous role and explore anger, grief, vulnerability and determination.

There are moments when she makes the emotional differences between the twins work. The character also gives her room to carry the story rather than simply exist within an ensemble of young actors.

However, the screenplay does not always provide enough emotional depth to make either sister fully compelling. A challenging double role needs more than contrasting personalities; it needs well-developed characters whose motivations audiences can understand. Kapoor shows promise, but the writing does not consistently support her performance.

Not the Glossy Campus Drama Audiences Remember

The series makes a deliberate effort to distance itself from the earlier films. The original Student Of The Year was built around youthful romance, privilege, competition and spectacle. After Dark replaces that world with psychological trauma, toxic relationships, social validation and a darker take on teenage ambition.

The Student of the Year competition itself is also given a disturbing makeover. Instead of relying on familiar sporting and dance challenges, the contestants face confrontational rounds that test their confidence and expose their insecurities. The later use of a hypnosis device to make participants confront their nightmares pushes the competition into psychological-thriller territory.

The show also touches on family conflicts, childhood trauma, friendship and the emotional consequences of growing up in an environment where everyone is competing for recognition.

Its music attempts to retain some of the franchise's youthful energy while adding suspense. Achint Thakkar's songs and Shalom Benjamin's background score contribute to the atmosphere. The visual treatment is another positive, creating a more unsettling version of the familiar school setting.

What Other Critics Are Saying

The response to Student Of The Year: After Dark has been largely mixed, with several reviewers agreeing that the concept is more interesting than its execution.

The Times of India awarded the series 3 out of 5 stars, praising Shanaya Kapoor's double role and Reema Maya's visual approach. The review highlighted the misty visuals, production design and background score, but noted that sluggish storytelling and underdeveloped characters weaken the overall impact.

NDTV gave it 2.5 out of 5 stars, describing the series as an exhausting Gen Z drama. Its review praised Kapoor's effort but criticized the weak writing, uneven supporting performances and the repeated use of cliffhangers and twists that do not necessarily make a thriller more engaging.

India Today also rated it 2.5 out of 5 stars, pointing to scattered storytelling, uneven performances and shallow characterisation. The review noted that the series struggles to balance its campus drama with its psychological-thriller ambitions.

Hindustan Times was more critical, giving the show 2 out of 5 stars. Its review questioned the coherence of the narrative, arguing that the series prioritizes suspense and shock value over a well-constructed story.

Meanwhile, The Telegraph observed that the show tries to combine a coming-of-age drama, murder mystery and commentary on Gen Z's obsession with validation, but struggles to bring these elements together effectively.

The common criticism is clear: the series has an intriguing premise, but its storytelling does not consistently deliver the tension or emotional investment expected from a murder mystery.

Final Verdict: A Darker Makeover That Needed a Stronger Mystery

Student Of The Year: After Dark deserves credit for taking a familiar franchise in a completely different direction. A frozen-lake death, a twin sister investigating a suspicious school environment and a competition built around psychological pressure offer a promising foundation.

Shanaya Kapoor's double role is a definite talking point, and the atmosphere gives the series a distinct identity. However, uneven writing, slow pacing and a mystery that becomes increasingly crowded with suspects and subplots prevent it from reaching its potential.

This is not the Student Of The Year audiences remember, and that is not necessarily a bad thing. The bigger problem is that the series wants to be a dark, layered psychological thriller but does not always know how to sustain the mystery.

Verdict: Watch it for Shanaya Kapoor's attempt at a challenging double role and the darker campus setting, but do not expect a tightly written murder mystery.