Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Submit Guest Post

Why has a US court issued a summon to former RAW chief Ajit Doval in the Pannun case?

A New York federal court has dispatched summonses to India's National Security Advisor Ajit Doval and former RAW chief Samant Goel in a civil lawsuit filed by Khalistani separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun over an alleged assassination plot.

India's National Security Advisor Ajit Doval

In this pool photograph distributed by the Russian state agency Sputnik, India's National Security Advisor Ajit Doval attends a meeting with Russia's President in Saint Petersburg on September 12, 2024.

Highlights:

  • A New York federal court has sent summonses to India's National Security Advisor Ajit Doval and former intelligence chief Samant Goel.
  • The lawsuit alleges an assassination plot against Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun.
  • The documents were sent through FedEx to three district courts in New Delhi.
  • The court authorized an alternative method of service after an earlier attempt was rejected.
  • India has dismissed the lawsuit as fabricated and malicious.

A US federal court has dispatched legal summonses to India's National Security Advisor Ajit Doval and former intelligence chief Samant Goel in connection with a civil lawsuit filed by Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, who alleges that Indian officials were involved in a plot to assassinate him.


The clerk of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York confirmed that the documents were sent through FedEx on Friday, November 20, to three district courts in New Delhi: Patiala House Court, Tis Hazari Court and Dwarka District Court.

The dispatch follows a November 13 order by US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla authorizing the issuance of summonses under provisions of the Hague Convention, an international agreement governing the service of legal documents across national borders.

In the order, Judge Failla requested assistance from Indian courts in delivering the documents to the two officials.

“The court respectfully requests the assistance of receiving Indian courts in effecting service of process upon the defendants in this civil action pending before this court,” the order stated.

What is the lawsuit against Indian officials about?

Pannun, legal counsel for the banned organization Sikhs for Justice (SFJ), has filed a civil lawsuit seeking damages over an alleged attempt on his life.

He has accused Doval of orchestrating a conspiracy involving India's external intelligence agency, the Research and Analysis Wing (RAW), to assassinate him. Goel, who previously headed RAW, is also among the officials named in the proceedings.

Pannun is wanted by Indian investigative agencies on multiple terrorism-related charges.

The allegations in the US lawsuit have been rejected by the Indian government. The issuance of summonses is a procedural step in the civil case and does not establish that the allegations are true or amount to a finding of wrongdoing by the officials named.

Why is the Hague Convention involved?

The Hague Convention provides a framework for courts in one country to request assistance from authorities in another country to deliver legal documents. It helps establish procedures for serving court papers when defendants are located outside the country where a lawsuit has been filed.

Judge Failla cited the convention and relevant provisions of India's Code of Civil Procedure to explain how the summonses could be transmitted through Indian courts.

Under the Indian legal provisions cited in the order, summonses issued by designated foreign civil courts can be transmitted to Indian courts and served as though they had been issued by those courts.

The order also noted that an earlier attempt to serve the documents through India's designated central authority under the Hague Convention had been rejected.

The US court subsequently authorized an alternative method of service under Article 19 of the convention and India's Code of Civil Procedure.

How were the summonses sent to India?

Before the latest dispatch, the US court had attempted to serve the documents last month through a diplomatic note issued by the US State Department to the Indian Embassy in Washington.

The November 20 dispatch through FedEx marks another attempt to deliver the legal documents. They were sent to three district courts in New Delhi, which have been asked to assist with the service process.

The development is significant because it concerns the procedure for serving US court documents on senior officials of a foreign government. However, it does not mean that the officials have been found liable or that the allegations have been proven.

How has India responded to the lawsuit?

New Delhi has strongly rejected Pannun's lawsuit, describing it as fabricated and malicious.

On November 10, India's ministry of external affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal objected to the allegations against senior Indian officials and said requests to serve judicial documents in the country must follow its designated legal channel.

“We reject the fabricated and malicious attacks on our high officials. Also, we reject the frivolous lawsuits. A request for serving of judicial documents in India can only be routed through India's designated central authority, which is the Ministry of Law and Justice,” Jaiswal said.

The latest dispatch brings renewed attention to the legal dispute between Pannun and the Indian government. The case remains a civil proceeding in the United States, with the allegations contested by India. The next developments will depend on the legal process, including whether the summonses are formally served and how the defendants respond.